opinion

Japan cannot 'smile' away its obligations: China Daily editorial

chinadaily.com.cn

Updated: 2026-11-22 21:23

Share - WeChat

At a news conference in Shenzhen after the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Economic Leaders' Meeting on Thursday, Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi reiterated that Japan's position on the Taiwan question had not changed and that the foundation of Sino-Japanese relations remained the four political documents. Yet when asked about her dangerous and erroneous remarks on Nov 7 last year that a Taiwan contingency could constitute a "survival-threatening situation" for Japan, she declined to clarify, dismissing the question as "hypothetical".

That's disingenuous. Takaichi's earlier provocative remarks were an attempt to use a hypothetical question as a pretext for advancing Japan's remilitarization. Her remarks last year were unequivocal. How does a question about something she said that she has refused to retract ever since suddenly become "hypothetical"? Such evasiveness cannot hide the contradiction between the Takaichi government's words and its actions.

For instance, Japan is considering an early decision on acquiring nuclear-powered submarines as part of its revised security policy, scheduled for adoption by the end of December. The proposed move would push Japan closer to becoming a de facto nuclear country.

Although nuclear-powered submarines and nuclear weapons are two different things, nuclear submarines are precisely the last piece of the nuclear puzzle that Japan's neo-militarists covet. Japan already has almost all the technology, materials and equipment necessary for making nuclear weapons. The one thing it truly lacks is a nuclear strike capability that can be projected globally.

Japan's Atomic Energy Basic Act restricts nuclear energy to peaceful purposes. More fundamentally, the proposal conflicts with Japan's "exclusively defense-oriented" security policy and its long-standing Three Non-Nuclear Principles. That is why the Takaichi government is eager to remove the institutional "stumbling block" as early as possible.

It is considering an emergency exception to the Three Non-Nuclear Principles to accommodate the entry of nuclear submarines into Japan. Labeling such changes as "technical adjustments" conveniently diminishes their political significance.

The Cairo Declaration, the Potsdam Proclamation, and the United Nations Charter all set out explicit provisions concerning the postwar restrictions Japan must accept and the obligations it must fulfill as a defeated nation in World War II. Takaichi's desperation to remove the "enemy-state clauses" from the UN Charter reflects Japan's ambition to cast off the legal constraints of the postwar order.

In Shenzhen, Takaichi invoked the historical documents between China and Japan as a convenient pretext to evade substantive questions, while at multilateral forums she has constantly cultivated the image of Japan as "peace-loving", even as she keeps accelerating Japan's push to acquire nuclear capacity. The unbridgeable gap between what she says and what Japan does explains why she chose to stonewall, when asked questions about her erroneous remarks on Taiwan.

Besides, some in Japan have tried to hype up the reception Takaichi received in Shenzhen during the APEC gathering. It is telling that these are the same people who had earlier worried that Takaichi might not even be invited.

The world sees clearly that China made appropriate arrangements for all participants in accordance with international practice. There is little reason to mistake standard diplomatic protocol as snubs, still less to turn it into a distraction from the substantive issues confronting bilateral relations.

If Takaichi genuinely wants to repair relations with China, she should begin by retracting her provocative remarks on China's Taiwan region and demonstrate that Japan's commitments are sincere through concrete actions. Knowing one's mistake but refusing to mend it is a fault in itself.

The meeting of the heads of state of China, Russia and the United States in Shenzhen on Thursday carries a wider message to Japan. More than 80 years ago, the three nations, the key anti-fascist forces in the world, fought shoulder to shoulder and achieved great victories, winning peace and tranquility for the world. The anxiety among Japan's right-wing forces following the historic tripartite summit speaks volumes that they are the very ones who regard the postwar international order as "shackles" to be cast off.

History has shown that whenever Japan's right-wing forces don their familiar mask of "smiles" and "courtesy", they are often quietly pursuing agendas of their own. The present is no exception.

Copyright 1994 -

Registration Number: 130349

Mobile