opinion

Manufacturing suspicion good business for some

By LI YANG | chinadaily.com.cn

Updated: 2026-11-20 23:21

Share - WeChat

In a statement released on Thursday, the Chinese Embassy in France condemned as "entirely baseless" the claim made on FranceInfo's evening program Les Informés that "the entire overseas Chinese community consists of Chinese spies", calling it "a malicious smear".

The allegation made by Vincent Crouzet, a French writer and security commentator, and other guests on the program, was so sweeping that it dispensed with the need for evidence altogether.

Rooted in Cold War thinking and ideological prejudice, the remark treats an entire ethnic community as a potential intelligence network, effectively erasing the distinction between national security and racial prejudice.

The broadcaster and those responsible should stop peddling such allegations, respect the dignity and reputation of Chinese communities in France and take concrete steps to remedy the damage.

The episode is more than an unfortunate television outburst. It illustrates how readily anti-China narratives travel across borders, acquiring the appearance of "credibility". Its logic has a familiar counterpart in the United States, where the controversy surrounding former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang is becoming a vehicle for a much larger political campaign.

The scrutiny around Huang is being exploited by hard-line members of the US Congress seeking to tighten restrictions on China's access to advanced semiconductors and overseas computing capacity. On Thursday, new US export-control rules took effect, extending licensing requirements to certain advanced computing equipment supplied to overseas data centers serving China-linked customers. The measure significantly restricts an important route through which Chinese companies could rent computing power abroad, rather than purchase chips directly. It reaches well beyond Nvidia, affecting the data-center operators, cloud providers and technology companies of several countries.

Nor are the commercial consequences confined to China. US chipmakers and technology companies risk losing customers, revenue and influence in one of the world's largest technology markets. Third-country operators face additional compliance costs and uncertainty. Chinese technology companies, meanwhile, must reassess their computing strategies. The result is a more fragmented global technology industry, not a more secure one.

Huang's scheduled questioning by US congressional committees in early December adds another combustible element. The incident suddenly became a fanfare after the US' midterm elections and before the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation meetings in Shenzhen, and Huang's interview is scheduled to take place shortly before the G20 summit in Miami. The timing gives the controversy significance beyond corporate governance.

It also puts US government officials who previously authorized Nvidia chip sales to China under political scrutiny. The prospect of congressional investigations can make even legally approved commercial decisions look politically hazardous.

This is McCarthyism in a modern technological guise: suspicion becomes a political asset, association becomes evidence and commercial engagement becomes a liability. The danger is a chilling effect extending from US companies to third-country businesses, universities and research institutions. Nobody needs to be formally accused of wrongdoing to decide that dealing with China is simply not worth the "political risk".

The wider political calculation may be even more consequential. By inflaming public hostility toward China, the anti-China hawks can make it harder for the US administration to pursue a more pragmatic course in dealing with China-related issues. They can also exploit anxieties about data centers, electricity consumption and whether artificial intelligence benefits ordinary Americans, potentially alienating voters who expect the MAGA promise of economic renewal to deliver tangible gains at home.

There is a cynical asymmetry here. Those advocating confrontation can press for restrictions while leaving the US administration that must manage the diplomatic consequences to absorb the fallout. If Beijing responds, the political costs may fall on the US administration, which is seeking to maintain stable relations with China and manage differences through consultations. The hawks, meanwhile, can claim vindication from the confrontation they helped provoke.

The loose accusations aired on French television are a spillover of this wider climate: they help normalize the suspicion that makes economic exclusion politically saleable. Crouzet and his fellow guests should not be allowed to present prejudice as expertise. Nor should governments mistake a temporary partisan advantage for a national interest. Dialogue and consultation may be difficult; manufacturing enemies is easier. But the latter sacrifices truth and the stability of global supply chains for little more than a short-lived victory in Washington's internal power struggle.

Copyright 1994 -

Registration Number: 130349

Mobile