opinion

Market realities limit the reach of Washington's Pax Silica

By Li Yang | chinadaily.com.cn

Updated: 2026-11-17 18:43

Share - WeChat

Pax Silica — Washington has found a new name for an old ambition: The initiative aims to establish a "trusted" ecosystem for artificial intelligence stretching from critical minerals and energy to semiconductors, data centers and frontier models. The language used in the initiative talks about "resilience" and "shared prosperity". Its strategic logic is less subtle: organize allies around a United States technology stack and make it harder for China to compete.

But the ambition has one fundamental flaw: AI is not an island that can be fenced off by signing ceremonies. China and the US are intertwined across its layers. They compete for chips and computing power, but operate in overlapping networks of suppliers, researchers, engineers, software, applications and customers. Minerals, factories, data centers and markets do not conveniently arrange themselves into political blocs according to geopolitical considerations.

Pax Silica's own declaration acknowledges this. It says economic value will flow "through and across all levels" of the global AI supply chain, from energy and minerals to manufacturing, infrastructure and new markets. That is interdependence, not separation. Washington can reduce particular dependencies and protect sensitive technologies. It cannot realistically exclude a major AI economy from the global ecosystem by drawing a political circle around selected partners.

Nor is this simply a "defensive" supply-chain exercise. The initiative aims to give Washington leverage over allies' investment choices and technology standards, while helping US companies secure market share. A partner may sign under political pressure; it may be less willing to pay a premium for systems that are less capable, more expensive or more risky.

Coming after the midterm elections, this push presents a show of resolve by the US administration amid domestic unease over data-center expansion and controversy surrounding the resignation of Nvidia's former CEO. But it also suggests anxiety. The US announced a supply-chain declaration under the Pax Silica framework with nine partners days before the expected China-US AI dialogue on the sidelines of the APEC gatherings in Shenzhen this week. Washington no doubt hopes the move will help strengthen its hand at the negotiating table.

The US Department of Commerce's Bureau of Industry and Security also issued an interim final rule on Monday restricting remote access to advanced AI semiconductors and imposing new export license requirements on five countries identified as "having a high risk of illegal chip transshipment". The rule formally closes "a cloud-computing loophole" that allowed companies in restricted nations — most notably China — to rent advanced US computing power through overseas data centers without physically importing the hardware.

Such actions run counter to the consensus reached between the two sides, undermine the legitimate rights and interests of Chinese enterprises, and destabilize global industry and supply chains.

Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Guo Jiakun said on Tuesday that the US is going so far as to arbitrarily interfere in normal trade and sci-tech cooperation between China and other countries to unreasonably suppress the development of China's high-tech industries by repeatedly overstretching the concept of national security and abusing export control measures. He denounced this as a textbook example of economic coercion and long-arm jurisdiction, and said that China will take necessary measures to firmly safeguard its legitimate rights and interests.

There is a financial risk to the US' extraordinary AI buildout. Observers have warned that the investment boom could end in painful retrenchment, citing infrastructure spending, debt and opaque financing. When valuations and national strategy depend so heavily on one technological wager, a sharp correction could hit technology shares, the wider stock market and the US economy.

Disputes over data-center projects in the US and elsewhere also highlight the politics of compute begin with land, power and water, not just chips. In Manila, for instance, protesters have challenged its implications for sovereignty, livelihoods, water and electricity, even as Philippine officials promote data centers as a path to industrial development.

China's open-source models have challenged the economics of the US' closed-source systems, giving developers lower-cost tools to adapt and deploy. Open source is not automatically safer, just as closed source is not automatically more secure. Vulnerabilities in the US' own proprietary systems demonstrate that AI security is a shared challenge. Casting security concerns in geopolitical terms can distract investors from a harder question: can expensive, tightly controlled models preserve their advantage as cheaper alternatives improve?

Chinese Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Mao Ning has pointed out, AI is a shared asset of humanity, and that there should be no drawing lines along ideological differences or forming exclusive groupings. All parties should work together for the development and governance of AI, so that it can better serve the common welfare of humanity.

Washington and Beijing should use their AI dialogue to establish channels for warning of serious incidents, share testing practices and prevent technical failures or misunderstandings from becoming political crises.

Some allies may sign where Washington points. Markets will make their own judgment. Developers and customers will choose the tools that deliver the most capability for the least cost. Pax Silica can shape a coalition. It cannot decree the future of AI.

The US side should approach the dialogue in a constructive spirit, allowing it to contribute to mutual understanding and the healthy development of the global AI industry.

Copyright 1994 -

Registration Number: 130349

Mobile