World

Divided stances on fossil fuel jeopardize COP31 deal

By Julian Shea in London | chinadaily.com.cn

Updated: 2026-11-23 01:27

Share - WeChat

The United Nations COP31 climate change talks taking place over time on the weekend in Turkiye have failed to reach an agreement after a dispute about fossil fuels.

UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said Sunday that he is "deeply disappointed that COP31 has ended without consensus on an overarching outcome.

"But this setback does not change the facts ... There may be no consensus in the negotiating room. There is no ambiguity in the science."

The European Union was leading a group of around 130 nations that want any agreement to include explicit language about transitioning away from fossil fuels. However, the fourth draft contains no mention of them.

The EU had warned it would rather have no deal than a bad one, and after Saturday's latest round of talks failed to make any headway, its climate commissioner Wopke Hoekstra told reporters "Let's be honest, there is a real 'no-deal' scenario here".

The two-week-long meeting should have ended on Friday, but went into overtime on Saturday before COP31 President, Murat Kurum, suspended business for the day, saying "outside this hall there are people who are living with the effects of climate change . . . We all have huge responsibilities and in line with these responsibilities (we need) to reach an outcome".

The France 24 news website says a draft deal published earlier in the week mentioned the need for a faster phasing out of fossil fuels, but following objections, a second version was published without mention of gas, oil or coal.

A letter written by Hoekstra and Darragh O'Brien, climate change minister of Ireland, which currently holds the rotating presidency of the EU, said the 27-member bloc "cannot join consensus on a package that would represent a substantive step backwards for global climate action".

Any text excluding mention of fossil fuels, the letter said, would be "perceived as a retreat from previous commitments, and as disproportionately accommodating the interests of continued fossil fuel production and consumption".

Although the EU is speaking up, it is not just on behalf of its own members. Antigua and Barbuda are two low-lying islands located in the area where the Atlantic Ocean meets the Caribbean Sea, which would be at particular risk from issues such as rising sea levels.

The islands' Environment Minister Michael Joseph said he was "very disappointed with how the text looks", noting that it was "quiet silent on fossil fuels… I can't honestly say that I'm okay with it passing", and Maina Talia, climate minister for the Pacific island nation of Tuvalu, said "if we cannot address the fossil fuel crisis, then we are wasting our time here".

More than 92,000 delegates from nearly 200 countries have attended the talks. The United States has no representation.

Addressing the Friday plenary session, China expressed serious concern that some parties were seeking to weaken or end the mechanism in the name of streamlining and efficiency.

It said the review was an established process and called on parties to discuss the timing and modalities of the third review at COP32, while drawing on the latest scientific findings and avoiding duplication with the global stocktake, a comprehensive assessment of the progress made in achieving the goals of the Paris Agreement.

Speaking for the Arab Group, Saudi Arabia also warned that efficiency and complementarity must not become a justification for abandoning an established process. The group called for agreement on the continuation of the third and subsequent reviews, with their modalities and timeline to be discussed at the next COP meeting.

Hou Liqiang contributed to this story.

Copyright 1994 -

Registration Number: 130349

Mobile