China

Emissions transparency index shows a wide gap in cities' data accessibility

By HOU LIQIANG in Antalya, Turkiye | China Daily

Updated: 2026-11-17 09:30

Share - WeChat

A wide gap remains among major cities around the world in the disclosure of climate and environmental information, with many still lacking regularly updated and readily accessible data, according to the Global City Green and Low Carbon Transparency Index.

The index, jointly developed by the Chinese Research Academy of Environmental Sciences and the Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs, assessed 100 cities across six continents, including 24 in China and 76 overseas.

The report was released on Saturday at the China Pavilion on the sidelines of the ongoing United Nations climate change conference in Antalya, Turkiye. Known as COP31, the summit opened on Nov 9 and will run through Friday.

Paris topped the ranking with 83.48 points, followed by London with 81.20 and Manchester with 78.42. New York and Amsterdam rounded out the top five. Beijing scored 70.43, ranking highest among Chinese cities and becoming the only Asian city to score above 70. Five other Chinese cities — Hong Kong, Shanghai, Hangzhou, Jinan and Wuhan — also scored above 60.

The index measures the transparency of publicly available information rather than cities' actual environmental quality or emissions reduction performance. It evaluates cities across four areas — climate, environment, ecology and green transition — which, respectively, account for 35 percent, 35 percent, 20 percent and 10 percent of the total score.

The findings revealed a significant global disparity in disclosure levels. The gap between Paris, which topped the ranking, and Asuncion, which came last, exceeded 70 points. Of the 100 cities assessed, 67 scored below 60, while 25 received fewer than 35 points.

Although climate commitments have become increasingly widespread, the disclosure of progress in implementing them remains limited. The report found that 92 cities had published basic or historical greenhouse gas inventory data, 86 had released formal climate action plans and 73 had announced net-zero or carbon-neutrality targets.

However, only 36 regularly disclosed annual progress in emissions reduction, while just 19 linked their climate targets to annual budgets. None provided information on independent third-party verification of their emissions inventories.

Regional performance also varied. European cities generally performed well in disclosing climate and ecological information, while Chinese cities demonstrated comparatively strong transparency in environmental monitoring, law enforcement and pollution-source information.

According to the report, 15 of the 20 leading cities in environmental transparency were in China.

Ma Jun, founding director of IPE, said the assessment aims to identify good practices, highlight governance gaps and encourage mutual learning among cities.

He emphasized that cities need to move beyond publishing policies and long-term targets by providing continuously updated, searchable and comparable data. This would enable the public to track implementation and help advance global low-carbon transition.

Ma said a number of cities in China and overseas had effectively improved their green and low-carbon transparency by using information technology to develop big data platforms.

He called on more cities to harness technologies such as remote sensing, the internet of things, artificial intelligence and environmental DNA to strengthen monitoring of ecological changes and facility operations, while developing their own information platforms.

Such platforms could eventually be interconnected to form regional and global environmental and climate data systems, supporting government decision-making, corporate accountability, public oversight, consumer choices, green trade and green investment and financing, he said.

"Such efforts would help coordinate reductions in carbon emissions and pollution with ecological conservation, accelerate the low-carbon transition and turn global commitments into concrete action," he said.

Copyright 1994 -

Registration Number: 130349

Mobile