Global ocean experts voiced concerns on Sunday over the political motives of a joint bid by Belgium and Chile to host the secretariat of a United Nations marine treaty, warning that the proposal could create legal uncertainty, increase operational costs and widen the digital divide facing the Global South.
The Agreement under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea on the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Marine Biological Diversity of Areas beyond National Jurisdiction, also known as the BBNJ Agreement, entered into force on Jan 17, aiming to conserve and sustainably use marine biodiversity in these areas.
The first meeting of the Conference of the Parties, scheduled for January 2027 at the UN Headquarters in New York, will decide where the secretariat will be hosted. Xiamen in Fujian province, Valparaiso in Chile and Brussels in Belgium are the three candidate cities.
However, Belgium and Chile announced on Nov 6 that they would merge their bids, proposing to locate the secretariat in Valparaiso while establishing the physical and technical infrastructure of the Clearing-House Mechanism, or CHM, in Brussels. The CHM is an information-sharing platform designed to facilitate the exchange of scientific, technical and legal knowledge.
Chinese Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Mao Ning, on Thursday, criticized the decision to bundle the secretariat and the CHM into a single package, describing the move as an attempt to hijack the selection process and force all parties to accept the arrangement. She said the move "politicizes and 'blocs' the bid, running counter to the spirit of multilateralism".
Speaking via video link at an international symposium in Haikou, Hainan province, Jayanath Colombage, former chief of the Sri Lanka Navy, said the BBNJ Agreement represents a major development in global ocean governance.
"Its success depends not only on where the secretariat is located, but on whether the institutions operate effectively, inclusively and independently," he said.
"For the Global South, the objective is to move from limited participation to meaningful influence in the governance of the global ocean commons. Hosting the secretariat in a Global South country is a symbolic contribution to addressing these inequalities, but institutional location alone cannot guarantee equitable outcomes," he said.
Colombage questioned the rationale behind splitting the secretariat's operations between two distant countries, stressing that Xiamen had demonstrated its ability to host the institution in one location.
"We should assess the bids on institutional merit, not let the selection become another arena of major-power rivalry," he added.
Wu Shicun, chairman of the Huayang Center for Maritime Cooperation and Ocean Governance, said the preparatory process had proceeded on the understanding that the BBNJ Agreement would have one host country and one headquarters agreement.
The political motives behind Belgium and Chile's unconventional approach has the potential to create significant uncertainty for the selection process and could seriously disrupt the first Conference of the Parties, Wu said.
He questioned the feasibility of separating the two facilities by about 12,000 kilometers.
Such an arrangement would substantially increase the financial burden on state parties and complicate the management of the CHM, which is intended to narrow the gap between developed and developing countries, he said.
It could also marginalize the secretariat, which the joint proposal says would be responsible for managing the CHM, making it difficult to ensure the mechanism's operational efficiency and transparency, he added.
Dhana Brillant, secretary-general of the Pacific China Friendship Association, said the merged bid warranted careful consideration, as it "raises important questions regarding coordination, operational efficiency, institutional responsibilities and the overall functioning of the secretariat".
Brillant described Xiamen as "a coherent and compelling proposition", citing its established institutions in marine science, ocean governance, environmental protection and sustainable development, as well as its infrastructure, scientific capabilities and institutional experience.
Xin Qiang, a professor at Fudan University, said the joint bid suggested that Belgium and Chile believed they "could not compete with China, at least as individuals". He warned that splitting the secretariat between two countries could blur the division of rights and obligations and lead to conflicts in global ocean governance.
China has stronger capabilities in marine governance, environmental protection, fishery technology and deep-sea exploration, as well as in addressing climate change challenges such as sea-level rise, Xin said. He added that China also hoped to assume greater responsibilities in marine governance, as reflected in its Global Governance Initiative.
Maeva Perez, a scholar at Hong Kong Baptist University, also expressed skepticism about the joint proposal, particularly its potential impact on data sharing. Perez said the CHM was more than just a server, as it involved personnel responsible for organizing data.
A newly established major organization needs room for trial and error, she said, adding that a geographical split would require responsibilities to be defined from the outset, potentially creating operational friction and unnecessary complexity.
Wu Weidi contributed to this story.
Contact the writers at limenghan@chinadaily.com.cn
