China has fulfilled almost all its commitments to the World Trade
Organization (WTO) since joining it more than five years ago. And it will meet
one of its last pledges next year if the ongoing session of the National
People's Congress (NPC) approves a draft.
The long awaited law on new corporate income tax is expected to take effect
in 2008, changing China's existing rates for domestic firms (33 percent) and
overseas-invested companies (15 percent) to a unified 25 percent. That will
provide domestic and overseas-funded firms with a level playing field for the
first time since the economic reforms began in the 1980s.
Overseas firms that have invested in sectors such as high-tech manufacturing
and services will, however, continue to enjoy the favorable treatment.
Companies from abroad have been enjoying the favorable tax structure since
they first tapped the Chinese market.
The government granted them the favor because they faced various investment
restrictions in some industries and sharing of stakes, says investment
researcher at the University of International Business and Economics Lu Jinyong.
"But we cannot grant them preferential treatment forever. They have to be
treated equally now, given that China has opened nearly all its markets to
foreign players."
In fact, the proposed 25 percent tax is low compared to most other countries.
Government data show the average corporate income tax rate in 159 counties and
regions was 28.6 percent in 2005-06, with the average rate in the Chinese
mainland's 18 neighboring countries and regions being 26.7 percent.
Ever since the subject of a unified corporate tax rate was raised, some
experts and analysts have been voicing concern that the move could hurt the
inflow of overseas direct investment into China. But Lu feels most
overseas-funded firms would not change their investment strategy in China in the
long run.
Why? Because, CITIC's China Securities analyst Hu Yanni says, a unified tax
regime is one of the factors that attracts overseas direct investment. The key
issues in China should be abundant human resources, social stability and an
irreplaceable market.
The new system, however, will be phased out over five years, with the tax
rate for investors from abroad being raised by 2 percentage points every year.
"Overseas investors have five years to adapt to the changes," Hu says. In fact,
a number of such businesses have already started internal adjustments to offset
the impact of a unified tax rate.
The changes in the corporate income tax rates are expected to benefit some
domestic industries. For example, a lower tax rate means higher profit for
domestic banks.
CITIC China Securities banking analyst She Minhua says a bank will see a 1 to
1.5 percent profit gain if the income tax is cut by 1 percent. Therefore, if
it's lowered from 33 to 25 percent, domestic banks could realize an added profit
of 8 to 12 percent. For a bank like the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China
(ICBC), which had a pre-provision profit of 78 billion yuan ($10.08 billion) in
2005, it means an added gain of 6 billion yuan ($775.19 million).
Domestic manufacturing companies involved in some traditional sectors would
be among the major beneficiaries. Most of such firms now have to pay a 33
percent income tax because they neither enjoy the favorable tax rates like the
overseas firms, nor any of the tax reductions given to domestic high-tech
businesses.
Analysts say sectors such as food and beverages, iron and steel, coal,
papermaking and non-ferrous metals, too, stand to gain from the tax cut.
An automobile business analyst, who doesn't want to be named, says:
"Commercial vehicle enterprises such as China National Heavy Duty Truck Group
Corp and bus giant Yutong Group may benefit a lot (from a unified tax policy)
because most of their funds come from domestic investors ."
The move is expected to prompt some domestic manufacturers in some
traditional industries to seek independent and national brands. Some firms now
earn most of their profit from joint ventures, which enjoy the preferential tax
rates, rather than from their wholly owned businesses.
Apart from the direct tax cut, domestic investors are also expected to
benefit from other measures in the proposed tax reform package.
If the new law is passed, domestic companies, like their overseas
counterparts, will be allowed to list all the wages they pay as costs, instead
of pre-tax deductible items.
Most Chinese companies get a wages deduction of only 1,600 yuan ($206.73) per
employee per month, meaning any amount they pay above that is not exempt from
corporate tax. "The pre-tax deduction of all paid wages is important for banks
because they have a large number of employees and a big wages bill," says She of
CITIC China Securities.
Bank of China and the ICBC have "already got the State Administration of
Taxation's approval" to raise their wage-deduction threshold.
The new tax system includes other measures that are expected to benefit
domestic firms and overseas investors both.
First, the new law will be based more on sectors than regions; preferential
tax rates will be granted to firms in high-tech sectors, particularly to biotech
and aerospace companies. Preferential rates will also be enjoyed by sectors such
as shipbuilding, equipment and machinery, banks, insurance, logistics and the
traditional labor-intensive service industry.
Second, the new tax system will encourage corporate firms to take up more
social responsibility by raising the deduction rate for donations.
Third, favorable tax rates will be extended to a wide range of sectors such
as environmental protection, energy preservation and agricultural
infrastructure.
Also, such preferential policies will be adopted across the country, instead
of focusing on specific regions.
Four, small-sized enterprises, accounting for a large percentage of
businesses, are expected to enjoy favorable tax rates or preferential measures.
(China Daily 03/09/2007 page8)