There is a substantial difference between motions submitted to a session of
the National People's Congress (NPC) and proposals to the National Committee of
the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC).
The difference lies in that as the NPC is the country's top legislature, an
NPC motion becomes legally binding when it is adopted; while a proposal to the
CPPCC National Committee, the top advisory body, is not legally binding whether
it is adopted or not.
NPC motions are submitted by NPC deputies or relevant departments to the NPC.
According to the Constitution, NPC deputies and members of the NPC Standing
Committee have the right to submit motions and proposals within the respective
functions and powers of the NPC and its Standing Committee in accordance with
procedures prescribed by law.
According to the Organic Law of the NPC and NPC rules for the discharging of
its duties, a motion on issues within the power of the NPC can be raised by the
presidium of the NPC, the NPC Standing Committee, special committees of the NPC,
the State Council, the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's
Procuratorate, a provincial-level delegation (of deputies) to the NPC, or a
group of at least 30 NPC deputies.
Afterwards, the NPC presidium decides if a motion is to be included in the
agenda of an NPC session, or to be first handed over to a relevant special
committee for examination. The special committee is to suggest to the presidium
whether or not the motion is to be included in the agenda.
A motion, after examination by NPC deputies at full meetings of delegations
or panel meetings, will be transferred by the presidium to a relevant special
committee for further examination. The presidium will examine the report from
the special committee and decide to submit the motion to a plenary session of
the NPC for a vote. Adoption requires a simple majority voting in favor.
Members of the CPPCC put forward proposals to offer comments and suggestions
on major political and social issues of the country to people's congresses and
the government via the CPPCC.
For the presentation of a proposal, there is no restriction on timing, scope
and number of sponsoring members. Generally, CPPCC members can raise a proposal
in one of the following ways:
-- by one member or a group of members;
-- by one group or more groups jointly during the plenary sessions of the
CPPCC;
-- in the name of a party or people's organization that has joined the CPPCC;
and
-- in the name of a sub-committee of the CPPCC National Committee.
A department in charge of handling proposals is obliged to give a reply to
each proposal. Generally speaking, an NPC motion is raised when the NPC is in
session; while members of the CPPCC can raise proposals at any time they wish.
