CHINA / National

China, India rediscover silk route ties
By Andy Mukherjee (Bloomberg)
Updated: 2006-06-13 06:34

The Western world's rediscovery of China and India has produced an important side effect: It has become a trigger for the two rising Asian superpowers to renew their own 2,000-year-old acquaintance.

It's still early days in the courtship, though if it continues, 2050 may not look much different from 1750 when the two nations together controlled as much as 57 percent of the world's manufacturing output.

This month, China and India will reopen the only all-weather overland trade route joining them through the Himalayas at 14,500 feet above sea level. The Nathula Pass was once part of the thriving Silk Route, connecting ancient China with India, the Middle East and Europe.

Nathula is still a work in progress: The crossing, in its present form, is suitable for mules, not big trucks. The more important point about the reopening of the pass -- it was closed after China and India fought a brief but bitter war in 1962 -- lies in the political symbolism of the move.

By opening Nathula, the two countries will be shaking off the diplomatic mistrust -- and the resulting economic constraints -- that has hindered the development of China's southwest and India's northeast and prevented the nations from tapping a reservoir of power, gas and oil in their backyards.

The resumption of trade along the 62-mile (100-kilometer) road that connects Gangtok, the capital of the northeastern Indian state of Sikkim, to the Tibetan town of Yatung in China's southwest involves subtle shifts in foreign policy that neither country acknowledges publicly.

Trade Versus Territory

The reopening of Nathula will underscore the Chinese government's abandonment of its policy treating the erstwhile Himalayan kingdom of Sikkim as an independent nation ``annexed'' by India in 1975.

As part of the grand bargain, India, too, has decided to soften its stance on Tibet.

Even as it continues to host Tibet's spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama, who has lived in exile in India since 1959, the Indian government has unequivocally accepted China's sovereignty over Tibet and agreed to forbid Tibetan settlers in India from carrying out anti-China activities.

With territorial politics largely out of the way, economic forces can finally take over.

The scope for trade is immense.

Landlocked parts of China's southwest, comprising the autonomous regions of Tibet and Guangxi and the provinces of Sichuan, Guizhou and Yunnan, have been left behind even as coastal regions in the east have benefited from investments and jobs in trade-linked manufacturing.

Southwest China, Northeast India

India's northeast has similarly suffered because of its geographic isolation.

If the two contiguous regions were developed in sync, they could become an economic powerhouse together, trading not just with each other but also with Bangladesh, Bhutan, Myanmar and Nepal.

China's southwest and India's northeast have 200 billion cubic meters of natural gas, 1.5 billion tons of crude oil and 900 million tons of coal reserves, according to economists Biswa Bhattacharyay at the Asian Development Bank in Manila and Prabir De at the Research and Information System for Developing Countries in New Delhi.

The Ganges and Brahmaputra rivers, which flow through India's east and northeast, have the potential to generate 90,000 megawatts of electricity annually. Only a fraction of this potential is being exploited because it is too expensive to transport the power to industrial centers in northern India.

A New Equation

The economics can change with trade.

``Massive investments are required for the development of the hydropower resources of the Ganges-Brahmaputra basin and can be productive with enhanced cooperation between China and India,'' Bhattacharyay and De say. ``Hydropower in India's northeast can be marketed in the southwest provinces of Bangladesh, China and Myanmar.''

Natural resources are becoming increasingly vital for both China and India. At the same time, policy makers in both countries are aware of the need to reduce regional economic disparities to preserve social harmony.

For six years now, China has been urging international enterprises to look beyond coastal China. The Chinese government's ``Go West'' policy has prompted companies such as Motorola Inc. and Intel Corp. to set up units in Chengdu, the capital of the western Sichuan province. With a matching ``Go East'' policy in India, China will find it easier to take investors further into the Chinese hinterland, into Yunnan and Tibet.

Early Days

The Indian port city of Calcutta is about 700 miles from Lhasa, the Tibetan capital. And Nathula is one of several links that can be prepared to handle efficient motorized cargo transportation between Calcutta and Tibet.

Cooperation between the world's two fastest-growing major economies is still nascent: It was only four years ago that China and India got their first direct flight between the two countries.

Since then, progress has been rapid. From April to December 2005, China and India traded goods valued at $12 billion, a 55 percent increase from a year earlier. In the next four years, Tata Consultancy Services Ltd. and Infosys Technologies Ltd., the two biggest Indian software companies, plan to have at least 15,000 employees in China between them.

To most analysts, China and India appear to be engaged in a race to prosperity. In reality, the two economies are quietly finding ways to work together, including making joint bids for oil assets to control acquisition costs.

 
 

Related Stories