Gay rights activists will
ignore an official ban on a march through Moscow this week despite warnings from
some within their community that it will only serve to whip up prejudice in
widely homophobic Russia.
Nikolai Alexeyev, organiser of the gay festival that will culminate in
Saturday's march, said it would show Russians the homosexual community is not a
threat to society.
But in a culture where church leaders lump homosexuality together with murder
and violence, and where skinheads try to storm gay clubs, other gays said they
preferred the quiet life.
"I think the time has come to go out and say we want equal rights. We are
paying our taxes just like all citizens," said Alexeyev, 28.
The Moscow city government has banned the march, calling it an "outrage to
society" and right-wing extremists have promised to attack marchers.
But Alexeyev said it would go ahead anyway.
"The main issue is the fight against homophobia and discrimination. We are
asking the authorities to ban discrimination on the basis of sexual
orientation," he said.
Two of the commonest Russian words for gay men -- pederast and homosexualist
-- suggest they either abuse children or are suffering from a medical condition,
and Alexeyev said he was trying to alter this mindset.
But other activists criticised his tactics, saying that making a display of
their sexuality risked undermining the gains made since homosexuality was
decriminalised in 1993.
Lyubov Sliska, a senior member of the Kremlin's United Russia party and
deputy speaker of parliament, was just one prominent member of the establishment
to oppose the march.
"Some people say a ban on the gay-parade would not accord with human rights,"
she told Russian reporters. "Several million people living in Moscow do not want
these homosexualists to hold an action. Who defends their rights?"
Much time must pass before such an attitude changes into one of acceptance,
said Ed Mishin, 33, founder of Queer magazine, the www.gayrussia.ru site and a
shop of gay-linked merchandise.
"We should not shout from the television screens. I am a supporter of the
quiet revolution," he said, saying publicity was provoking homophobes like those
who forced police to evacuate Moscow's Three Monkeys gay club at the end of
April.
"This has produced no uniting of gays, and homophobia has risen. Now the
authorities are negative to any gay organisation," he said.
He said the fact that skinhead groups who have previously targeted foreigners
were now planning attacks on gay clubs was a sign that the march had backfired.
Alexeyev disagreed. He said he had forced gay issues onto the news agenda
while Mishin merely worried about his business.
In a discussion of gay rights on the state-controlled NTV channel last week,
he sparred with an Orthodox priest who said southeast Asia was hit by the
tsunami and New Orleans was flooded because they tolerated gays.
"Why do you want the destruction of your people," the priest shouted,
predicting a Biblical-style catastrophe if the march went ahead, to loud
applause from the studio audience.
Alexeyev said such publicity was useful, and would get Russians used to the
fact that gays were living among them.
"People will see that the sky does not fall, that there will be no flooding
of Moscow, and people will ask why these people can't have the same rights as
all the others," he said.