The voluntary carbon trade lacks global rules or a central registry --
emissions could in theory be sold more than once. Prices for a ton of non-toxic
carbon dioxide vary widely.
"The market is growing fast. We're hoping for commonly accepted standards in
coming months," said Renate Heuberger, managing director of Swiss-based
myclimate.org which is helping soccer's governing body FIFA at the World Cup
finals in Germany.
FIFA plans to offset 100,000 tons of carbon dioxide linked to travel by World
Cup spectators. Under one project, it and the German tournament organizers will
invest in replacing coal-fired boilers at a South African factory with boilers
run on sawdust.
Some environmentalists are skeptical of the offset projects, particularly
forest plantings since they say many saplings die.
They want the world to focus on axing fossil fuel use.
"'Plant a tree and fly guilt-free' is obvious nonsense," said Steve Sawyer of
Greenpeace.
Yet with growing public concern about global warming, some businesses find
that it pays to go green.
HSBC says it became the world's first carbon neutral bank in 2005 by
investing in clean energy projects such as a wind farm in New Zealand to offset
emissions from its core operations.
HSBC bought 170,000 tons of carbon dioxide for $4.4 per ton for the fourth
quarter of 2005, a total of about $750,000. Some environmentalists say HSBC
should extend its scheme, which excludes the carbon impact of its loans.
Gore's movie calls itself the "first carbon neutral documentary." But Gore
was criticized after he was spotted driving 500 meters to a screening at the
Cannes film festival.
The World Bank said this month it would offset 148,000 tons of emissions to
become "carbon neutral."
The projects are springing up in parallel to the
United Nations'
Kyoto Protocol, which obliges 35 industrial nations to cut emissions by 5.2
percent below 1990 levels by 2008-12.
President George W. Bush pulled the United States out of Kyoto in 2001,
saying it would cost jobs and wrongly excludes developing nations. The United
States is the world's number one source of carbon dioxide, emitting about 24
tons per person.
"If you only look at U.S. politics you miss how much the average person has a
concern for these issues," said Jack Groh, director of the National Football
League's environment program.
organizers of the Super Bowl, won by the Pittsburgh Steelers in Detroit in
February, planted enough tree seedlings to cover 3.5 acres and soak up 260 tons
of carbon.
BEWILDERING VARIETY
World Cup organizers are buying "certified emission reductions" (CERs)
created by a Kyoto scheme for promoting investments in clean energy in
developing countries, with an additional quality stamp known as the "gold
standard."
"This is a market with very different currencies, we believe that CERs will
be the benchmark," Heuberger at myclimate said.
He said that CERs bought for the World Cup cost almost 10 euros (US$12.58) a
ton. In a
European Union market set up under Kyoto, prices are around 15
euros a ton.
Shopley's company -- founded before Kyoto started -- relies mostly on
"verified emissions reductions" (VERs), checked by external auditors but often
cheaper than CERs. VERs are often energy projects too small to qualify for Kyoto
mechanisms.
For travelers, Web sites can be bewildering.
For one passenger flying from Paris to Sydney, for instance, Carbon Neutral
reckons emissions are 1.9 tons, but Germany's Atmosfair reckons the emissions
total 5.99 tons, due to a "high altitude surcharge."