Chinese banks defy doomsayers' prediction
By RICK CAREW (THE WALL STREET JOURNAL)
Updated: 2006-01-25 14:30
When China joined the World Trade Organization in 2001 -- committing to open
its then-struggling banking sector to full competition by 2007 -- skeptics
predicted the country's banks would be swamped by better-capitalized foreign
This week, as leaders at the World Economic Forum's annual meeting in Davos,
Switzerland, debate the fiscal fitness of China's banks, it appears the
doomsayers have been wrong, or at least premature. China has injected fresh
capital into its biggest banks, set up corporate boards with independent
directors and pushed them to list abroad. Foreign investors have responded by
putting up more than $16 billion for pieces of Chinese banks.
Few foreign banks look poised to take on the daunting task of building a vast
retail-banking network of their own from scratch. At the end of October, the
assets of foreign banks were just 2% of total banking assets in China.
Instead, foreign institutions are scrambling to invest in China's banks.
Chinese have poured 14 trillion yuan ($1.736 trillion) -- about 46% of the
country's gross domestic product -- into bank accounts each year. "As income
levels rise, millions more people will become attractive banking clients," says
David Marshall, Fitch Ratings' head analyst for banks and financial institutions
in Asia. "That is drawing the attention of foreign banks."
The lure for both domestic and foreign banks is China's undeveloped
consumer-finance market. The share of consumer loans among total loans grew to
11% from 5% between 2000 and 2004.
In its WTO commitments, China promised to allow foreign banks to tap into
China's local-currency retail-lending market and its 1.3 billion consumers at
the end of 2006. Foreign banks will be able to issue yuan-denominated loans and
accept yuan-denominated deposits from Chinese individuals. Currently, foreign
banks are allowed to offer loans and accept deposits in foreign currency, and to
provide yuan-denominated services to enterprises in 25 cities. But few foreign
banks have built such a network with local-currency retail customers still off
"It's not going to be a doomsday scenario for the domestic banks when
December 2006 comes," says May Yan, senior banking analyst at Moody's Investor
Service in Hong Kong. "The December event will only have an impact over the next
five to 10 years."
HSBC Holdings PLC of the United Kingdom has the largest foreign bank network
in China, with 12 branches. In contrast, Industrial & Commercial Bank of
China, China's largest domestic bank, has more than 20,000 outposts.
"We have a two-pronged strategy: Grow our business organically and through
cooperation with our strategic partners," said Richard Yorke, chief executive of
HSBC China. HSBC has invested more than $5 billion in China, the most among
foreign banks, but more than $4 billion of that has gone into equity investment
in local financial institutions -- including a 19.9% stake in China's
fifth-largest bank, Bank of Communications.
China's banking regulator has capped the maximum amount of foreign investment
in a single domestic bank at 25% and a maximum stake for a single investor at
20%. But in September, the China Banking Regulatory Commission said it was
reviewing the caps on foreign bank ownership and intends to raise them gradually
before the end of 2006. Analysts expect the caps to remain under 50%.
To attract strategic investors while helping domestic banks become more
competitive, China recapitalized three of the biggest state-owned commercial
banks by injecting $60 billion. The fresh capital and sale of nonperforming
loans were enough to attract giants Bank of America Corp., Royal Bank of
Scotland PLC and Goldman Sachs Group Inc. to take stakes in the three
recapitalized domestic giants ahead of their initial public offerings.
Chinese government officials describe the introduction of foreign strategic
investors as "win-win" -- foreign banks get to share in the China growth story
while domestic banks become more competitive by adopting international
risk-management strategies, developing key business segments and attracting
But buying into China's biggest banks also has limitations and risks. When
taking a 9% stake in China Construction Bank Corp. in June, Bank of America
agreed not to open new retail operations in China and to close existing retail
operations there. Strategic investors in CCB and Bank of China have also been
required to lock up their shares for three years, making it difficult for
investors to get out if new problems are discovered at domestic lenders.
Blockbuster deals such as Bank of America's CCB deal and Singapore state
investment firm Temasek Holdings Pte. Ltd.'s 5% stake in the same bank --
representing a combined $5.4 billion investment -- also carry political risks.
Domestic critics noted those two investors paid less than 1.2 times book value,
then watched the bank's IPO fetch 1.95 times book value just months later.
But perhaps the largest question is whether injecting capital and bringing in
foreign investors will be enough to end poor risk management. The combined
nonperforming loans of China's four biggest state-owned banks dropped to 10.11%
from 19.15% of total loans over the past 18 months, but the ratio still is high
by Western standards. U.S. banks typically have nonperforming-loan ratios under
"Nobody knows how much of new loans will become nonperforming loans," says
Fitch's Mr. Marshall, adding that the effectiveness of China's risk-management
overhauls won't be apparent until the banking system goes through a full credit
Foreign investors with a long-term focus on China, including HSBC and
Citigroup Inc., are buying larger stakes in midsize banks in hopes they will
eventually be able to take full control. But China's willingness to allow
foreign banks to call the shots at its domestic banks remains unclear.
For example, Citigroup is leading a consortium seeking an 85% stake in
Guangdong Development Bank, with Citigroup taking a 40%-to-45% piece and control
of the bank. The deal would require a special exception from regulators and
usher in a new era of foreign ownership.
But a group headed by Soci¨¦t¨¦ G¨¦n¨¦rale SA, seeking to wrest the stake from
the Citigroup consortium, is arguing that an exemption would encourage other
foreign banks to ask for larger stakes. The French lender is making a
last-minute plea to Beijing to accept its lower bid, noting it would remain
under the current investment caps. A decision by China's cabinet is expected by
the end of the month.