Home>News Center>World

WTO lets EU, others hit US with sanctions
Updated: 2004-11-27 08:08

The World Trade Organization gave final approval on Friday to the European Union, Japan and others to hit the United States with an initial $150 million in trade sanctions in a dispute over an illegal anti-dumping law.

"They've got the go-ahead," said Kenyan ambassador Amina Mohamed, chairwoman of the WTO's Dispute Settlement Body.

Barry Virkler tosses an apple while sorting Cortland apples before they are put in cold storage at North Star Orchards Tuesday, Sept. 21, 2004 in Westmoreland, N.Y. The World Trade Organization on Friday, Nov. 26, 2004, approved stiff sanctions on a wide range of American exports that could include apples, cod, and heavy machinery intended to punish the United States for failing to repeal what it considers protectionist legislation said Amina C. Mohamed, Kenyan ambassador to the WTO and chairwoman of the organization's dispute settlement body. [AP]
When asked about the step, US President Bush pledged to work with Congress to ensure the United States complies with the WTO, while urging the global trade body to hold Europe accountable for "unfair" subsidies to aircraft maker Airbus.

"I'll work with Congress to get into compliance," Bush said in Crawford, Texas, where he is vacationing on his ranch.

The case involves the so-called Byrd amendment, which the WTO has repeatedly said breaks trade rules by handing out duties raised in anti-dumping cases to U.S. firms.

The White House has asked Congress to drop the law, but it is popular with legislators, who see it as a way to level the playing field for companies hurt by dumping, defined as exporting goods at below the cost of production.

Bush also struck back at Europe over subsidies for Airbus, saying: "We expect the WTO, as well, to treat our trading partners as they treat us. And that's why, for example, I filed (a) complaint on the Airbus situation."

The anti-dumping case, along with the aircraft dispute, which saw the United States and Europe file tit-for-tat complaints last month over support for Airbus and U.S. rival Boeing, are among several pitting Brussels against Washington.

The opening round of punitive duties -- which will be reviewed each year -- is relatively modest, when compared with the $4 billion the EU was awarded in a case over corporate tax breaks. But the figure could soar in coming years.

The lion's share of the right to retaliate goes to the European Union and Japan, since their companies are the most affected. Brussels has warned it could slap additional duties on U.S. goods early in 2005 if Washington does not repeal the law.

"We are delighted that the authorization confirmed our case. ... We hope that the U.S. will bring the legislation as soon as possible into conformity (with international rules)," EU trade spokeswoman Claude Veron-Reville said in Brussels.

The green light for sanctions was automatic because the case has exhausted all the WTO steps for settling disputes, including appeals and arbitration. Only a unanimous decision by all 148 WTO member states, including those seeking the sanctions, could have blocked it.

Both the EU and Japan, given the right to additional levies of $50 million and $80 million, respectively, by arbitrators, have presented the WTO with a list of products they plan to hit -- ranging from sweet corn to metals and textiles.

Canada, which along with Brazil, South Korea, India, Mexico and Chile is also involved in the complaint, has said that it is studying whether to impose sanctions and on what.

The U.S. amendment has been applied to billions of dollars of imports of Canadian softwood, the subject of a separate dispute between the two North American neighbors. Ottawa has said its WTO-authorized sanctions could reach $720 million in 2007, if the measure stays on the statute books.

The WTO decision was delayed 48 hours after the United States, in a rare late objection, demanded assurances that the requests for punitive duties were in line with limits fixed by the trade arbitrators.

  Today's Top News     Top World News

Ukraine parliament calls election invalid



WTO lets EU, others hit US with sanctions



Eight students slain; attacker arrested



People need better AIDS, HIV information



Anti-corruption drive to dig deeper



Graduates compete for government posts


  WHO: Flu pandemic inevitable, plans needed
  Ukraine rivals fail to resolve stalemate
  Barghouthi drops election bid
  Leading Iraq parties call for election delay
  WTO lets EU, others hit US with sanctions
  Bush: Iran nuke pact must be verifiable
  Go to Another Section  
  Story Tools  
  Related Stories  
US unlikely to abolish trade protection act
WTO deals new blow to 'big power' farm subsidies
WTO OKs plan to end farm export subsidies
China a top anti-dumping target -- WTO
  News Talk  
  Are the Republicans exploiting the memory of 9/11?