| Building better, stronger foundations
2004-04-13 China Daily
Premier Wen Jiabao has signed the Regulation on Foundations Administration
into promulgation, and the document will come into force on June 1.
It marks a significant step in China's efforts to boost its market economy.
Helping others with one's own wealth is not a new virtue, but an established
institution specifically designed for this mission only came into being at the
start of the 20th century.
Originally dedicated to aiding the poor, disabled and children, foundations
later diversified their strengths into developing education, scientific research
and environmental protection.
Now various foundations act as a medium between the government and the
market, offering resources to people and fields not covered by public service or
public goods supplied by the government.
As a result, the role of foundations is also referred to as the "tertiary
allocation" of society.
In traditional socio-economic theory, the first allocation is done through
the market according to the law of market economy.
The second allocation is done by the government with its administrative
power, like collecting taxes and aiding the poor. The second allocation could
meet needs the market cannot satisfy.
As society develops, public demands and interests are so varied that the
government can no longer supply public services or management to accommodate
everyone's need.
The third allocation operates on a totally different mechanism. Those
involved in foundations only seek rewards through self-fulfillment and social
esteem. As a result, foundations are institutes embodying human kindness and
dedication under the modern system of market economy.
There are 1.2 million foundations in the United States and the total volume
of donations amounts to US$670 billion every year, which is to say, the wealth
cycling by the tertiary allocation takes 9 per cent in the US GDP.
China's newly promulgated regulation marks a beginning of the development of
foundations in this country.
International experience indicates such development requires several
preconditions, the first of which is a sound market economy.
Market economy lays a solid base for the progress of foundations. Without
such an economic system, social wealth cannot be accumulated to a degree
sufficient for what is required to finance foundations, never mind boosting the
value of the funds. This eliminates the possibility of sustained development of
foundations.
The second precondition is protection of private property.
During last spring's outbreak of SARS (severe acute respiratory syndrome),
many wondered why wealthy residents of the Chinese mainland were not as active
in donating as those in the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. Probably,
they were following a traditional way of hiding their wealth for fear of causing
envy or even hatred. They were also probably afraid their private property would
not be protected.
The Regulation on Foundations Administration was signed soon after the
National People's Congress passed the constitutional revision.
Instead of being a coincidence, the constitutional revision about stepping up
private property protection added a new engine for the growth of foundations in
China.
The third precondition is social credibility.
There are often complaints that many foundations do not operate in a
trustworthy way.
This is true. That's the result of distrust - a fear that foundations are not
responsible for their behaviour.
As a matter of fact, examples are not rare of individuals abusing people's
trust by embezzling money under the name of some foundations.
But such examples should not be used to ask the government to doubt,
supervise or take over every foundation.
The regulation stipulates that civil servants should not take key positions
in foundations, but foundations are still required to be subject to the
"leadership" of certain government departments. That demands credibility of the
related departments.
The last necessary precondition is perfection of the legal system, especially
when it comes to drafting relative legislation aimed at the same target as the
regulation, like tax reduction for donors and financial supervision on
foundations.
With these conditions met, "kindness to strangers" will become part of
China's social fabric and the entire nation will prosper.
The author is director of the Institute of Social Development of the Shanghai
Academy of Social Sciences |